Skip to content 
Thinking about creating custom challenge coins but worried about the cost? You’re not alone! Many people are drawn to the idea of crafting these meaningful keepsakes—whether it’s to honor achievements, foster unity, or celebrate milestones—but hesitate because of budget concerns.
The good news? Custom challenge coins can cost as little as $1.90 per coin for bulk orders, with prices typically ranging from $3 to $5 per coin, depending on the design, materials, and order size. Even better, there are strategies to save money while still creating a coin that meets your needs.
In this guide, we’ll break down the key factors that influence the cost of custom challenge coins and show you practical ways to maximize value without breaking the bank.
Why Challenge Coin Costs Vary
Custom challenge coins vary in price based on several factors, including size, material, design complexity, and quantity. As a direct manufacturer, we ensure that you pay for actual production costs—without unnecessary markups from middlemen. Below, we’ll break down the key cost factors and how you can optimize your budget.
1. Design Complexity: More Than Just Looks
The design of your coin significantly affects its cost. Here’s why:
- 2D Designs – Clean, flat surfaces with clear outlines.
- 🎯 Estimated cost: $2.50–$3.00 per coin (for 300+ orders).
- 3D Designs – Sculpted details with raised elements for a premium look.
- 🎯 Typically $3.50–$5.00 per coin, depending on detail.
🛠 Cost Factors: More intricate 3D details require specialized molds and additional production time, which increases the overall cost.
💰 Money-Saving Tip: Opt for a 2D design if you want to keep costs down while maintaining a professional look.
2. Size and Shape: Bigger Isn’t Always Better
- Standard Round (1.5″–2″) – Most cost-effective option.
🎯 Typical cost: $2.00–$4.00 per coin. - Larger Coins (2.5″–3″) – Increased material use raises the price.
🎯 Expect $4.50–$7.00 per coin. - Custom Shapes – Unique outlines like shields, badges, or mascots.
🎯 Starts at $3.50–$6.00 per coin due to custom mold costs.
🛠 Cost Factors: Non-standard shapes require custom mold cutting and longer production time.
💰 Money-Saving Tip: Stick to standard sizes to avoid extra mold fees.
3. Material Choices: From Budget to Luxury
- Zinc Alloy – Lightweight and cost-effective.
🎯 Commonly used for budget-friendly coins, priced at $2.50–$3.50 per coin. - Brass & Copper – Heavier, more durable options.
🎯 Typically $3.50–$5.50 per coin. - Dual-Plating & Antique Finishes – Enhances aesthetics but adds cost.
🎯 Expect an increase of $0.50–$1.50 per coin.
🛠 Cost Factors: The material choice affects both durability and cost, with brass and copper being premium options.
💰 Money-Saving Tip: Choose zinc alloy if budget is a priority, or brass for a balance between cost and quality.
4. Order Quantity: The Bulk Savings Secret
- Smaller Orders (50–100 Coins) – Higher cost per unit due to mold setup.
🎯 Average: $3.50–$5.00 per coin. - Mid-Sized Orders (300–500 Coins) – Lower per-unit price.
🎯 Drops to $2.50–$3.50 per coin. - Bulk Orders (1,000+ Coins) – Maximum savings.
🎯 Can go as low as $1.90–$2.50 per coin.
🛠 Cost Factors: The more coins you order, the more the setup cost is distributed, lowering the per-unit price.
💰 Money-Saving Tip: Plan ahead and order in bulk to take advantage of lower pricing.
5. Special Features: Adding a Personal Touch
- Edge Engraving & Cutouts – Adds customization but increases labor costs.
🎯 Adds $0.30–$1.00 per coin. - Glow-in-the-Dark Enamel & Dual-Plating – Unique finishes that add to the cost.
🎯 Adds $0.50–$1.50 per coin. - Spinning & Moving Parts – Mechanical elements require additional production time.
🎯 Costs start at $4.00+ per coin.
🛠 Cost Factors: Special effects require extra labor and unique tooling, impacting production time and cost.
💰 Money-Saving Tip: Select only the most impactful features to balance customization with affordability.
6. Mold Fees: An Upfront Investment
A mold is required to create the base design of your coin.
- Standard Mold (Simple Shapes & Designs) – $50–$100 per mold.
- Complex Mold (3D or Custom Shapes) – $150–$300 per mold.
🛠 Cost Factors: Molds are reusable for repeat orders, making them a worthwhile investment.
💰 Money-Saving Tip: Reuse molds for future orders to save on setup fees.
7. Packaging Options: Presentation Matters
WhileStandard PVC Pouch – Included with all orders at no extra cost.
Velvet Boxes & Acrylic Cases – Enhance presentation but add cost.
🎯 Expect $0.50–$3.00 per unit depending on material.
🛠 Cost Factors: High-end packaging improves perceived value but increases overall expense.
💰 Money-Saving Tip: Use premium packaging selectively for special occasions or high-value recipients.
How to Get the Best Value
Here are some tips to maximize your budget:
- Start Simple: Avoid overly intricate designs unless necessary.
- Order More: Bulk orders significantly reduce the cost per coin.
- Choose Standard Options: Sticking to standard sizes and materials keeps costs manageable.
- Plan Ahead: Last-minute orders may incur rush fees.
- Leverage Discounts: Factorypin regularly offers promotions like free mold fees or bulk order discounts.
Price Ranges at a Glance
- Zinc Alloy, Standard Size: A standard-sized (1.5″ to 2″) challenge coin made of zinc alloy with a simple design and considering the average price, could cost around $3.00 to $6.00 per coin in bulk orders.
- Brass or Copper, Detailed Designs, Dual Plating:
- Material: Brass would add 20-30% to the base cost compared to Zinc.
- Detailed Designs: Intricate designs and 3D elements increase costs.
- Dual Plating: Adding dual plating could cost an additional $0.70 per coin.
- Estimated cost: Such a coin could start at $7 and go up to $15 or more.
Get a Quote from the Source
💡 Want a precise cost estimate for your custom challenge coins? Contact us for a free, no-obligation quote. We’ll help you balance quality, design, and budget to create the perfect coin at the best price possible.
