Skip to content 
If you’re trying to decide between soft enamel pins and hard enamel pins for your custom project, you’re in the right place. Most people looking up this comparison are likely creating their first custom enamel pin — and this guide is built to help you make that decision faster and easier.
What’s the Difference?
At the most fundamental level, the difference between soft enamel and hard enamel pins comes down to how the metal lines and enamel colors sit relative to each other:
Hard enamel pins: the metal lines and enamel colors sit flush on the same level, resulting in a smooth, flat surface.
Soft enamel pins: the metal lines sit higher than the enamel color areas, creating a textured surface you can feel.
Below is a quick comparison to help you scan the key differences at a glance.
| Feature | Soft Enamel Pins | Hard Enamel Pins |
|---|---|---|
| Best Use Cases | Complex linework, vintage styles, event pins, souvenirs | Cartoon characters, bold color designs, retail-quality pins |
| Cost Difference | Typically starts around $0.78 per piece | Usually starts slightly higher, around $0.84 per piece |
| Production Time | About 10–15 days for most designs | 15–20 days for simple designs; complex artwork can take up to 40 days |
| Plating Flexibility | Supports all plating types, including antique and rainbow finishes | Limited to standard, durable platings |
Which Should You Choose?
When deciding between soft and hard enamel pins, consider three things together: your design, your use case, and your budget.
As a general guideline:
- If you’re working on sports medals, corporate events, or large-scale promotional pins, soft enamel is usually the more practical choice.
- If you’re creating cartoon characters, collectible pins, or products meant for retail sale, hard enamel often delivers the finish customers expect.
That said, these aren’t rigid rules. If production time and budget allow, personal preference still plays a role. Both enamel types are durable and long-lasting—the key is choosing the one that aligns with how your pin will actually be used.
Why Are They So Different?
The real differences between soft and hard enamel pins don’t come from design trends—they come from how the pins are manufactured.
This isn’t a design preference — it’s a manufacturing limitation.
Color & Plating Sequence
- Soft enamel pins are plated first, then filled with enamel color.
- Hard enamel pins are filled with enamel color first, then plated after baking.
This single difference explains why soft enamel pins support more plating options.
Certain finishes—such as antique plating and rainbow plating—require dipping the pin into multiple chemical solution baths. If enamel colors are already applied (as with hard enamel), these chemical processes can permanently damage or alter the colors.
That’s why hard enamel pins are limited to more stable, standard platings such as:
- Gold
- Silver
- Copper
- Black nickel
- Rose gold
Soft enamel pins, by contrast, can use virtually all plating styles, including antique, rainbow, chrome, matte, and dual plating.
The production process also explains the differences in price and lead time.
With soft enamel, all enamel colors are filled at once, and the pin is baked a single time at the end of the process.
With hard enamel, each color must be:
- Filled individually
- Baked in an oven
- Polished flat
before the next color can be applied.
As a result:
- The more colors your design has, the more baking cycles are required
- Production time and cost increase linearly—and in some cases exponentially—as color count rises
If you’re still unsure which enamel type fits your design, our Factorypin team has over 20 years of experience helping creators and businesses turn artwork into high-quality custom pins. Contact us for a free quote or design review—we’re happy to help you choose the right option while keeping your budget and timeline on track.
