Skip to content 
If you’re trying to decide between soft enamel pins and hard enamel pins for your custom project, you’re in the right place. Most people looking up this comparison are likely creating their first custom enamel pin — and this guide is built to help you make that decision faster and easier.
What’s the Difference?
The biggest difference between soft enamel and hard enamel pins is how they look and feel.
Soft enamel pins have raised metal lines, with the colored areas sitting lower, creating a bumpy, textured surface. Hard enamel pins, on the other hand, have a smooth, polished surface — the metal and the colors are flush and even.
Soft Enamel vs. Hard Enamel: Quick Comparison
| Feature | Soft Enamel Pins | Hard Enamel Pins |
|---|---|---|
| Finish | Textured, raised metal lines | Smooth, polished surface |
| Color Style | Recessed, vibrant colors | Flat, clean, polished color finish |
| Shading Detail | Better for shading and intricate designs | Harder to achieve shadow effects |
| Durability | More prone to scratches over time | Scratch-resistant, long-lasting |
| Plating Options | Wide variety of metal plating options | Fewer plating choices due to polishing process |
| Cost | Lower cost, faster production | Slightly higher cost, longer production time |
| Best For | Souvenirs, giveaways, vintage looks | Corporate gifts, high-end collectibles, jewelry-like finish |
Why Are They So Different?
The main reason for these differences comes from how they’re made. Let’s break it down simply:
Soft Enamel Pins:
- The metal base is stamped to create recessed areas.
- Colors are filled in but stop short of the surface, leaving raised metal edges.
- The metal plating happens before the color fill, allowing more diverse plating options like:
- Antique finishes (antique gold, antique silver, antique copper)
- Dye plating (black dye, white dye, or custom colors)
- Rainbow plating (an iridescent, oil-slick effect)
- Matte finishes (matte black, matte gold, matte silver)
- Dual plating (combining two different metal finishes in one pin)
Hard Enamel Pins:
- The metal base is stamped, and colors are filled all the way to the top, level with the metal lines.
- The entire pin is polished flat, creating a smooth, shiny finish.
- Plating happens after the colors are baked, which can cause slight color shifts and limits plating styles to more durable options like:
- High-polish gold, silver, or copper
- Black nickel (a glossy dark finish)
- Gunmetal (a dark, muted metallic look)
This plating sequence is why soft enamel pins often have more creative plating styles, while hard enamel pins prioritize a clean, jewelry-like appearance.
Which Should You Choose?
Ultimately, the choice comes down to your preference and project goals. Do you want a textured, classic feel or a sleek, smooth finish? Both styles are durable and long-lasting — it’s more about the aesthetic and vibe you’re going for.
To give you a clearer picture, here are some examples from customers who’ve worked with us:
Still unsure? Our Factorypin team has over 20 years of experience helping creators and businesses design and produce custom enamel pins. Reach out today for a free quote — we’re happy to guide you through the process!
FAQs
Q: Are soft enamel pins suitable for outdoor use?
Soft enamel pins can handle some exposure to the elements, but their raised texture makes them more prone to wear and tear over time. If the pin will be frequently exposed to rain or sunlight, consider adding a protective coating or choosing hard enamel for enhanced durability.
Q: Can soft enamel pins include transparent colors?
Yes! Soft enamel pins can incorporate transparent enamel to create a stained-glass effect. This is a popular option for designs with intricate details or a need for unique visual depth.
Q: What are the best pin attachments for durability?
- Soft Enamel: Butterfly clutch or rubber clutch attachments are commonly used, but for added security, magnetic or locking backs are better.
- Hard Enamel: Stick pins or safety pins are great options for heavy-duty wear on clothing or bags.
Q: Are soft enamel pins lighter than hard enamel pins?
No, the weight difference is minimal since both types use the same metal base. However, hard enamel pins may feel slightly heavier due to their smooth and polished finish.
Q: How do I clean and maintain my enamel pins?
- Cleaning: Use a soft, dry cloth to wipe away dirt and smudges. For stubborn stains, a gentle soap solution and a soft toothbrush work well.
- Storage: Keep pins in a dry place and avoid prolonged exposure to direct sunlight to preserve their color and finish.
