Skip to content 
Designing a custom challenge coin isn’t just about making a cool piece of metal—it’s about creating a story, commemorating achievements, or fostering camaraderie. Get it right, and your coin will be cherished for years. Here are 7 essential design elements to guide you in creating a stunning and memorable challenge coin.
1. Choosing the Right Shape and Size
The shape and size of your challenge coin play a crucial role in ensuring your design not only stands out but also serves its intended purpose. The right choice can make a lasting impression, while the wrong one can leave important details lost or difficult to appreciate.
Common Shapes:
- Round: The traditional choice, ideal for military units, service awards, or commemorative coins. Its symmetrical form works well for balanced designs that emphasize central imagery or text.
- Oval: Ideal for event coins or designs with multiple elements. The elongated shape allows for extra space to incorporate more details or provide room for text.
- Shield: A popular option for law enforcement or security-related coins, symbolizing protection and authority.
- Custom Shapes: Unique forms, such as dog tags, logos, or silhouettes, create a distinctive design that stands out and adds a personal touch.
Size Recommendations:
- 1.5 inches: Lightweight and easy to carry, perfect for everyday use.
- 2 inches: The most common size, offering a good balance between portability and design space.
- 2.5 inches or larger: Ideal for coins intended for display or featuring highly detailed artwork.
Size and Shape Combinations:
Special shapes may require larger sizes to capture intricate details accurately. For instance, shield-shaped or highly custom designs often perform best at sizes 2 inches or larger to maintain clarity and impact.
Pro Tip: If your design includes intricate details, such as small text or detailed images, consider opting for a larger size to ensure these elements remain legible and impactful.
2. Selecting the Metal Finish
The metal finish you choose significantly influences the overall appearance and durability of your challenge coin.
Common Metal Finishes:
- Polished Gold: Bright and eye-catching, perfect for prestigious awards or celebratory coins.
- Polished Silver: Sleek, professional, and timeless. Ideal for coins representing authority or achievement.
- Antique Gold, Silver, or Bronze: Provides a vintage, classic look. Ideal for reducing glare while enhancing intricate details.
- Black Nickel: Sleek and modern, ideal for futuristic or minimalist designs.
Choosing the Right Finish:
- Durability: Antique finishes are less likely to show wear over time, making them ideal for coins that will be handled frequently.
- Design Compatibility: Consider the contrast between metal and enamel colors for optimal readability.
- Preservation: For long-lasting designs, protective coatings can be applied to preserve the finish.
3. Incorporating Meaningful Symbols and Text
Symbols and text convey the true meaning behind your challenge coin. Striking the right balance between these elements is key to creating a coin that resonates with its audience.
Text Proportion Tips:
- Text should occupy no more than 30% of the coin’s surface. This maintains a clean and readable design while emphasizing the coin’s symbols and imagery.
- Font Size: For clear printing, use a minimum font size of 12 pt for coins that are 1.75 inches or larger. Avoid using overly intricate fonts that may be difficult to read at smaller sizes.
Placement Tips:
Meaningful Dates and Slogans: Choose significant dates, mottos, or phrases that resonate with the purpose of the coin. Keep the text brief, impactful, and legible.
4. Deciding on Color Enamel
Color is one of the most exciting aspects of challenge coin design—it breathes life into your coin and helps communicate its purpose. However, choosing the right color scheme requires thoughtfulness.
Design Considerations:
- Simple Designs: Use bold, contrasting colors to create strong visual impact.
- Detailed Designs: A more subdued color palette is better for intricate designs to avoid overwhelming the viewer.
- Cost: The number of colors you use can impact the cost of production. Fewer colors generally reduce costs, but using transparent enamels can create unique effects that enhance the design.
Pro Tip:
Consider using transparent enamel over certain areas of the coin to allow the metal finish to shine through, adding depth and texture to the design.
Cost Factors:
- The number of colors affects pricing; fewer colors generally reduce costs.
- Transparent enamels can create a unique effect by showing the metal finish underneath.
5. Adding Edge Design
The edge of your challenge coin may seem like a minor detail, but it can significantly enhance the visual appeal and tactile experience of the coin. A well-chosen edge design can make your coin feel more substantial and polished.
Common Edge Types:
- Standard Edge: Clean and simple, suitable for straightforward designs.
- Rope Edge: Adds a decorative touch, often used for maritime-themed coins.
- Diamond-Cut Edge: Enhances the coin’s elegance with reflective cuts.
- Beveled Edge: Provides a modern and polished appearance.
Historical Context:
Some edge designs, like the rope edge, have origins rooted in traditional nautical or military coin designs, symbolizing unity and strength.
6. Considering Additional Features
Adding unique features to your challenge coin not only enhances its visual appeal but also increases its functionality. Think of these as ways to elevate your coin beyond a mere memento.Enhance your coin’s functionality and uniqueness by adding extra features:
- Bottle Opener: Combine form and function by incorporating a bottle opener element.
- 3D Relief: Add depth and dimension for a striking design.
- Glow-in-the-Dark Enamel: Make your coin visible in low-light conditions.
- Cutouts: Create unique shapes or symbols within the coin.
These additional features can make your coin not just a keepsake but also a practical tool or artistic expression.
7. Choosing a Reputable Manufacturer and Partnering for Success
Selecting the right manufacturer is crucial for bringing your design to life.Your choice of partner will determine the quality and craftsmanship of your final product.
Key Considerations:
- Experience and Expertise: Choose a manufacturer with a proven track record of creating high-quality challenge coins. Look for one that specializes in your type of design—whether it’s military, corporate, or commemorative.
- Customization Options: Ensure the manufacturer offers the finishes, features, and design flexibility you need to execute your vision perfectly.
- Customer Service: A reputable manufacturer should offer excellent customer service, clear communication, and timely delivery.
At Factorypin, we pride ourselves on delivering superior craftsmanship, expert design advice, and unparalleled customer service. Whether you’re crafting a military coin, corporate memento, or commemorative piece, we’re here to help you every step of the way.
Conclusion
Creating the perfect custom challenge coin is all about balancing design elements to convey your message clearly and beautifully. By following these 7 key elements—shape, size, metal finish, symbols and text, color enamel, edge design, and additional features—you can craft a coin that truly stands out.
Ready to bring your custom challenge coin design to life? Contact us today for expert design advice and superior craftsmanship.
One Response