Skip to content 
Struggling to come up with a unique challenge coin design? Whether you’re honoring a police department, military unit, sports team, or corporate event, finding the right idea can be tricky. You want something meaningful, eye-catching, and well-crafted. This guide will walk you through creative challenge coin ideas, showcasing real examples to help spark your inspiration.
1. Unique Edge Designs
The edge of a challenge coin might seem like a small detail, but it can add a lot of character. Here are two examples:
Spur Edge for Police Challenge Coins
One of our designs features a police challenge coin with “Law Enforcement” on the back and an image of Saint Michael, the patron saint of law enforcement. The spur edge gives it a rugged, bold look, reinforcing the strength and resilience of police officers.
Rope Edge for a Local Police Department
The Albany Police Challenge Coin was designed as a token of appreciation for the department. The rope edge adds a sense of tradition and unity, making it feel more ceremonial and prestigious.
2. Irregular Shapes for a Bold Look
Who says challenge coins have to be round? Custom shapes make a coin stand out instantly.
Sports-Themed Coin
The New England Sports Challenge Coin takes on an unconventional shape, incorporating the team name and highlighting their 2019 Runner-Up achievement. This creative approach makes the coin more than just a keepsake—it tells a story.
Shield-Shaped Military Coin
The 14th PSYOP Battalion Challenge Coin is shaped like a shield, symbolizing protection and strength. This is a great example of how a coin’s shape can align with the message it carries.
3. Dual-Sided Designs for More Impact
Using different designs on each side allows for more creativity and meaning.
ST LUCIE county sheriff’s Office Coin
One side features a colorful logo protected with epoxy resin (which helps keep the design intact over time), while the other side is a raw metal finish with Saint Michael’s image. Saint Michael is often associated with protection and justice, making this a fitting tribute to law enforcement. This combination of techniques makes the coin both visually striking and long-lasting.
4. 3D Raised Details for a Premium Look
Adding 3D elements makes a coin feel more dynamic and luxurious.
Disney Challenge Coin Featuring Picsou
This coin uses raised 3D elements to bring the beloved Picsou character (known as Scrooge McDuck) to life. The extra depth and detail make the design pop, giving it a premium look and feel.
5. Cut-Out Designs for a Unique Touch
Cut-out designs create visual interest and can emphasize key elements.
Secret Service Challenge Coin
This coin features a cut-out center, forming a bold star shape. The open space draws attention to the central design, making the star stand out even more. This technique works well for adding depth and uniqueness to a coin.
6. Vibrant Colors with Enamel
Enamel fills add bright, eye-catching colors that make a coin more appealing.
Girl Scouts Challenge Coin
This coin bursts with color, featuring the phrase “We’ve Got It” and a special message from the CEO. The use of enamel enhances its lively and youthful look, making it a fun and memorable keepsake.
7. Different Plating Options for a Premium Finish
Plating affects the overall appearance and feel of a challenge coin. Here are some common options:
| Plating Type | Description | Best For |
|---|---|---|
| Gold Plating | Shiny, luxurious, and elegant | Award coins, high-rank military coins |
| Silver Plating | Classic and timeless | Police, firefighter, and commemorative coins |
| Antique Brass | A vintage, rugged look | Historical or military coins |
| Black Nickel | Sleek and modern | Tactical or law enforcement coins |
| Dual-Plating | A mix of two finishes for contrast | High-end custom designs |
8. Bottle Opener Coins for Extra Functionality
A challenge coin doesn’t have to be just for display—it can be useful too!
Air Force Research Laboratory Challenge Coin
Designed in the shape of a triangular lab beaker, this coin doubles as a bottle opener. This design adds both practicality and personality, making it a great keepsake for those in the research community.
9. Elegant Packaging for a Memorable Gift
Presentation matters! A well-designed challenge coin deserves a high-quality gift box. Packaging enhances the perceived value, making the coin feel even more special when gifted.
Final Thoughts
There are endless ways to make your challenge coin unique—whether it’s through edge detailing, custom shapes, dual-sided designs, 3D elements, or creative plating.
If you’re feeling inspired, we’re here to help bring your ideas to life! Contact us today to start designing your custom challenge coin.
