Skip to content 
Designing an enamel pin isn’t as simple as drawing a cute picture and sending it to a factory. It’s a creative journey that involves research, design precision, and production know-how. Without a clear strategy, your pins may end up costing more than expected, losing essential design details, or suffering from unwanted color changes.
But don’t worry — in this guide, we’ll walk you through every step of the design process. From turning your ideas into production-ready designs to saving money during manufacturing, we’ll cover everything you need to know.
By the end of this guide, you’ll know how to:
- Create designs that grab attention and sell well.
- Make sure your design looks just as good in real life as it does on your computer screen.
- Control production costs while still creating premium-looking enamel pins.
Ready to design a pin that sells, stuns, and saves you money? Let’s dive in.
1️⃣ From Idea to Impact: How to Create a Pin Design That SELLS
Why this step matters:
Every successful enamel pin starts with a killer concept. But here’s a crucial truth: a great pin design isn’t just about looking good — it’s about selling well. If you’re selling to collectors, event planners, or businesses, you need to design pins that match what customers actually want to buy.
How to ensure your pin will sell:
- Trendy Themes: Cute pins never go out of style. Who doesn’t love cute designs? If you’re unsure about your theme, going for a cute or playful design is always a safe bet. Beyond that, large-scale events like sports tournaments, popular bands, movies, and TV shows provide rich inspiration. Fans of specific genres like anime or Disney characters are often passionate and willing to buy themed pins. Tailoring your designs to fit these interests can help you connect with a niche yet dedicated group of buyers.
- Creating Emotional Connection: Think about your audience’s preferences and choose a market segment that speaks to you. For example, anime fans are likely to be very loyal to certain themes, so if you’re into anime, you’re sure to find a community of people who share the same interest and are eager to buy pins related to it.
- Use Visual Appeal: To stay ahead of the curve, consider adding extra layers of creativity like bold outlines, intricate detailing, or innovative themes that speak to current pop culture trends.
Pro Tip:
If you’re considering launching on platforms like Kickstarter, look at successful past campaigns to learn which elements resonated with backers. This can help you shape your design to ensure it appeals to a broad audience.
If you’re ready, focus on building hype before the campaign starts. Show mockups, share “in-progress” designs, and let backers feel part of the creation process.
2️⃣ Design Smarter, Not Harder: How to Create Production-Ready Designs
Why this step matters:
You’ve got a killer concept — but is it ready for production? The difference between a successful design and a production nightmare comes down to line thickness, file quality, and color separation.
How to ensure your design is production-ready:
- Use a vector file format (.AI, .EPS, .SVG) — No JPEGs or PNGs! Vector files keep your design sharp and scalable, so nothing gets blurry.
- Check line thickness: Make sure every line in your design is at least 0.5mm thick. Thin lines are difficult to fill with enamel, leading to broken details.
- Avoid super small details: If you’re adding facial expressions, eyes, or mini symbols, enlarge them so they stay clear when shrunk to pin size.
- Separate colors with metal trim lines: These dividing lines act as barriers for each color. Without them, colors may “bleed” into each other.
3️⃣ From Screen to Reality: How to Avoid the Color Shift Trap
Why this step matters:
On your screen, your design looks vibrant, bold, and perfect. But once your enamel pin is produced, the colors might look dull or “off.” Why? This is called a color shift, and it’s one of the most common complaints in enamel pin production.
How to avoid color shift:
- Use Pantone colors (PMS), not RGB or HEX — Using the Pantone system ensures consistency in color across all stages of production, from design to final output. Unlike RGB or HEX values, which are optimized for digital displays, PMS colors are specifically designed for print and manufacturing.
- Request a pre-production sample — If color accuracy is critical, ask your manufacturer for a sample before full production.
- Watch out for metal plating reflections — Gold, silver, and nickel plating can make colors appear warmer, cooler, or shinier than expected.
4️⃣ Size Matters: Pick the Right Size for Your Pin
Why this step matters:
Too big, and your pin becomes expensive. Too small, and your design details disappear. Finding the right size is key to creating a pin that’s both affordable and visually appealing.
Which size is right for you?
- 1 inch — Great for simple, minimal designs.
- 1.25 inches to 1.5 inches — The most common size. Offers a balance of detail, impact, and affordability.
- 2 inches+ — Best for statement pieces, but costs increase due to material use and weight.
What you can do next:
Print your design at 1 inch, 1.25 inches, and 1.5 inches. See how it looks in each size. Does it still look clear at 1 inch? If not, you may need to simplify the design.
5️⃣ Keep Costs Under Control (Without Sacrificing Quality)
Why this step matters:
If production costs get out of hand, your project could lose money. But there are ways to keep costs low while still creating a high-quality product.
6 Smart Ways to Cut Costs Without Cutting Quality
- Reduce the number of colors: Fewer colors = lower production costs. Stick to 2-3 colors, and use smart shading techniques to create depth.
- Order in bulk: When you increase your order size (e.g., from 100 to 300 pins), the cost-per-pin drops significantly.
- Look for promotions: Factorypin often runs “no mold fee” promotions, saving you around $50-$100 in upfront costs.
- Material & Effects: The finish and special effects you choose will determine your pricing and overall product quality. If your design is intricate but you’re on a budget, consider UV printing as it allows for detailed designs with cost-effective results. For designs that require a high-gloss metal finish, consider working with a factory that uses real gold and silver plating. Many factories offer gold plating, but it’s often a gold-tone plating, which can look overly yellow and fake. On the other hand, genuine gold plating offers a more refined and authentic look.
- Plating & Metal Choices: Pay close attention to the finish, as nickel plating is commonly used in silver-plated pins, but it may not give the same luxurious feel as genuine silver plating. In some cases, the color difference between nickel and silver is almost indistinguishable to the eye, but the price difference will speak volumes in terms of quality.
- Cost Balancing: If your pins are selling well, many factories will retain molds for 1-2 years, so you can avoid mold costs on reorders, saving a significant amount on subsequent runs.
Pro Tip:
Soft enamel pins are usually cheaper than hard enamel pins. If your design has lots of raised details, soft enamel might be the smarter choice.
6️⃣ Don’t Forget the Backing! (Your Pin Should Stay Put!)
Why this step matters:
Imagine your customers lose your pin after one wear because it fell off their jacket. Annoying, right? The backing is often overlooked, but it’s critical to user experience.
Which backing should you choose?
- Butterfly Clutch — Low-cost and secure.
- Rubber Clutch — More secure and doesn’t poke the skin.
- Magnetic Back — Great for high-end pins or delicate fabrics.
- Double Pin Posts — Ideal for larger pins to prevent spinning.
What you can do next:
If your pin is 1.5 inches or larger, consider using double pin posts. This prevents spinning on jackets or backpacks.
7️⃣ Selecting the Right Factory: The Key to Perfect Pins
While the design is crucial, the factory you choose to manufacture your pins can make or break the quality of the final product. Choosing the right manufacturer is essential for ensuring your design comes to life exactly as you envisioned it.
How to choose the right factory:
A skilled factory will use the Pantone Matching System (PMS) to ensure that the colors you select are accurately reproduced. Even though color adjustments are done by hand, experienced factories have the know-how to match your design as closely as possible to the digital file. Their expertise in this area can significantly impact the final product’s appearance and quality.
Factory Recommendations:
When you work with Factorypin, you’re not just getting a manufacturer — you’re getting a design partner. We review your designs, catch potential production issues, and even help you reduce costs.
Here’s what sets us apart:
- No mold fees during promotions — Save $50-$100 on production costs.
- Free design review — We’ll check your file for line thickness, color issues, and production compatibility.
- Custom effects — Glow-in-the-dark, glitter, rainbow plating, and more!
- Fast production — Get your pins in weeks, not months.
Ready to Bring Your Pin Design to Life? Here’s Your Next Step!
If you’ve followed this guide, you’re already ahead of 90% of first-time pin designers. From crafting a winning concept to ensuring production perfection, you’ve got the tools you need to succeed.
But you don’t have to do it alone. Factorypin is here to help. Our team has helped artists, brands, and Kickstarter creators bring their designs to life.
👉 Get a free design review from Factorypin today and turn your dream pin into reality.
