Skip to content 
Choosing the right challenge coin size is crucial—it affects the design, cost, and overall impact of your coin. Too big, and you might overspend on materials; too small, and key details could be lost. So, how do you find the perfect balance? This guide will walk you through the factors to consider when selecting the ideal coin size, ensuring it meets your design vision while staying within budget.
Standard Coin Sizes and What They’re Best For
Most challenge coins fall between 1.5″ and 2.5″. Each size comes with its own pros and tradeoffs. Based on our production experience, here’s how they compare:
| Size | Ideal Use Case | Pros | Tradeoffs | Avg. Weight (approx.) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1.5″ | Budget-friendly, simple logos | Easy to carry, low cost | Limited detail space | ~22 g |
| 1.75″ | Balanced choice for most designs | Good detail, not bulky | Slightly more cost | ~28–30 g |
| 2.0″ | Detailed or 3D elements | Visual impact, more room | Heavier, more expensive | ~38–42 g |
| 2.5″+ | Display pieces, collector editions | Maximum presence | High cost, not portable | 60g+ |
Which Size Works Best for Specific Use Cases?
Not all coins are round, and not all are meant to be carried. Some are designed to open bottles; others are shaped like shields or stars. If you’re planning a functional or specialty coin, here’s a quick size guide based on what our customers typically choose:
| Use Case | Recommended Size | Why | Portable? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bottle opener coin | 2.0″ (min. 1.75″) | Smaller coins don’t provide enough grip or leverage for actual use | ❌ Bulky for pockets |
| Custom-shaped coin (e.g. star, shield) | ≥ 2.0″ | Non-circular shapes need more space to preserve design clarity | ✅ if thin material used |
| 3D sculpted coin | 2.0″ – 2.5″ | Extra space allows better relief and visual depth | ⚠️ Gets heavy over 2.5″ |
| Budget or giveaway coin | 1.5″ – 1.75″ | Most cost-effective and easy to mass produce | ✅ Very portable |
| Award or presentation coin | 2.5″+ | Premium look, max visual impact | ❌ Often too heavy for everyday carry |
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a 2.5″ coin too heavy to carry?
It depends on the material and thickness, but in most cases—yes. A 2.5″ solid metal coin can weigh over 60g, which feels bulky in a pocket or on a keychain. These are best used as display pieces, awards, or limited edition items.
What’s the most popular size for general use?
2.0″ is by far the most popular. It offers a sweet spot between space for details and ease of handling. It’s large enough to showcase logos, 3D elements, and enamel colors—without becoming too heavy.
Can a 1.5″ coin still look good?
Absolutely, especially for simple designs. If you’re working with a clean logo, single color, or text-based design, a 1.5″ coin is cost-effective and easy to carry. But if your design includes fine lines, shading, or multiple elements, you might want to size up to 1.75″ or 2.0″.
Do larger coins always cost more?
Generally, yes—more material, higher plating cost, and increased shipping weight all contribute. But the total cost also depends on your design complexity. Sometimes a slightly larger coin avoids the need for custom molds or design edits, saving money overall.
Want to Dive Deeper?
If you’re looking for more in-depth guidance, check out these related posts:
- 👉 How to Make Your Own Coins? Easy Step-by-Step Guide
- 👉 7 Key Elements for Designing a Challenge Coin
- 👉 9 Best Challenge Coin Ideas to Make Your Design Stand Out
Still not sure which size is right for your coin?
Contact us anytime — we’ll review your design and help you choose the best size, free of charge.
